The evidence gathered was used in a trial that resulted in defendants conviction. Lower courts applying robinson and chimel, however, have approved searches of a variety of personal items carried by an arrestee. This opinion is subject to formal revision before publication in the preliminary print of the united states reports. In its opinion below in what became united states v. Justice sonia sotomayor was alone in her concurring. Legal arguments in 2004, the fbi and the metropolitan police department began investigating antoine jones for a narcotics violation.
Texas we might expect an ideological split with justices roberts, alito, thomas who though he didnt speak in the other cases voted with the conservative bloc, and possibly kennedy on one side and justice breyer, kagan, sotomayor, and ginsburg on the other. She ruled in the majority which upheld the affordable care act twice, and in obergefell v. Justice sonia sotomayor pleads for the fourth amendment. Supreme court of the united states andrew kisela v. United states, holding that a warrant is required for police to access cell site location information from a cell phone companythe detailed geolocation information generated by a cellphones communication with cell towers. I was at the supreme court this morning for the oral argument in united states v. Sotomayor does not view the constitution as settled law. Justice sotomayor s concurring opinion in united states v. Scalia in that case tried to decide whether government could put a gps transmitter in a suspects car without a warrant. Jones, an approach that excludes fourth amendment protection to digital data stored with others is. Fourth circuit adopts mosaic theory, holds that obtaining. The government acknowledged, however, that jones was the exclusive driver. Sotomayor in a solo concurring opinion and justice alito, joined by. According to justice scalia, writing for a majority of the court in jones, the police performed a fourth amendment search of antoine jones because they attached a gps tracking device to joness property without his consent, thereby committing a trespass on.
Not long ago i was sternly lectured by professor michael ramsey of the university of san diego for an irreverent post about justice antonin scalias opinion in united states v. Justice sotomayor joined the majority opinion, agreeing that many questions could be left for another day because the governments physical intrusion on jones s jeep supplies a narrower. Jones, a case restricting the government from placing g. Apr 19, 2016 if the justices hold true to past form in united states v. The first hispanic and third woman appointed to the united states supreme court, sonia sotomayor has become an instant american icon. Supreme court unanimously confirmed that americans have constitutional protections against gps surveillance by law enforcement, holding that gps tracking is a search under the fourth amendment. Nov 12, 2015 tucked away in roberts elegant reasoning was a citation of united states v. We decline here to create a new exception to a rule so well established in the context of criminal. That is the precedent of the court and settled, in terms of the holding of the court. It further suggests that this goal is best achieved when the court exercises its authority using just.
Jul 14, 2009 sotomayor replied, the courts decision in planned parenthood v. Police placed a gps device on defendants car without a warrant. Police use of gps is ruled unconstitutional the new york. Based on information gathered through various investigative techniques, police were granted a warrant authorizing use of a gps tracking device on the jeep registered to jones wife of which jones was the exclusive driver, but failed to comply with the. An introduction to the men and women who decide the worlds cases waltham, mass 2007.
A new court ruling means that privacy doesnt require secrecy. Feb 15, 2012 part one in this series of columns appeared on justias verdict on february 8, and can be found here. Jones, which exemplifies her attempt to stake out a middle ground approach to fourth amendment debates over surveillance and technology, and foregrounds intimacy. In a hotly anticipated decision, the supreme court unanimously found that the governments warrantless attachment of a global positioning system gps tracking device to a vehicle to monitor its movement constituted a fourth amendment violation. Sonia sotomayor, associate justice, was born in bronx, new york, on june 25, 1954. Justice ruth bader ginsburg is the only one to have an illustrated workout book. Jan 27, 2014 justice sotomayors concurring opinion in united states v. Hodges, to legalize samesex marriage in all 50 states. In this essay, professors tyler and meares highlight the ways in which recent social science research supports the model of jurisprudence articulated by justice sotomayor. As justice sotomayor noted in jones, the government, by itself and through its.
Todays historic nomination of judge sonia sotomayor to the united states supreme court from the court of appeals for the second circuit has. Sotomayor was born in the bronx on june 25, 1954 to juan sotomayor and celina baez, both native puerto ricans. She was the first hispanic and the third woman to serve on the supreme court. Writings by justice sotomayor grouped by type, in alphabetical order by first party name. My beloved world debuted at the top of the new york times best seller list for hardcover nonfiction for the week of february 3, 20, a position it retained for several weeks. Sotomayor was confirmed on august 6, 2009 by a vote of 6831 articles books by forward, the international judge.
Appointed by president barack obama, sotomayor became the first hispanic supreme court justice. Sotomayor has joined a growing number of jurists who argue that the law may not have kept up with the huge increase in available information. Jan 23, 2012 one of the puzzles of jones is how scalias opinion ended up being the majority opinion of the court, while justice alitos view is merely a concurring opinion. She is the third woman to become an associate justice of the supreme court. Im going to update the post as i go, so general readers can get the important stuff first at the top and then general readers can get the rest down the page. Circuit introduced a new mosaic theory of the fourth amendment. They may both have illustrated books, but they have even more in common when it comes to writing. Justice sotomayor does not formally join the alito opinion, but her sympathy for its finding of a fourth amendment search in gps monitoring is fairly obvious, as she expresses.
The puzzle is that the apparent 5th vote for the jones majority, from justice sotomayor, wrote a concurrence strongly hinting that she would accept a far broader rationale something akin to that in justice alitos concurrence in. The court of appeals reversed the conviction on fourth amendment grounds. Jones, secretary, florida department of corrections steven anthony cozzie 177545 v. It is also an early assessment of her performance on the court, her relationships with her colleagues, and the particular influence she is likely to exert on future decisions. In this post, i want to blog my reactions to the argument. The lecture touched on topics including justice sotomayor s conception of her role and her jurisprudence, her agreements and. As predicted, chief justice roberts authored the majority opinion, reversing the. How justice sotomayors concurring opinion may impact trade secret law and the computer fraud and abuse act by john marsh on february 6, 2012 posted in computer fraud and abuse act cfaa, intellectual property, social media, trade secrets.
A biography is an overview of justice sotomayors life and career from her childhood to her ascent to the supreme court. The essay analyzes justice sotomayor s already oftdiscussed concurrence in united states v. Supreme court decision electronic frontier foundation. Under that theory, whether government conduct is a search is measured not by whether an individual act is a search, but rather whether the collective sum of the different acts over time amount to a search. Now, with a candor and intimacy never undertaken by a sitting justice, she recounts her life from a bronx housing project to the federal bench, a journey that offers an inspiring testament to her own extraordinary determination and the power of believing in oneself.
As supreme court justice sonia sotomayor noted in her 2012 concurring opinion in united states v. In march 2007, a grand jury returned another indict 1. In carpenter case, justice sotomayor tries to picture the. The supreme court decides the gps case, united states v. Scalia the two conservative supreme court justices brawl over technology and privacy. Sotomayor sworn in as supreme court justice the new york times. Jones that federal agents had violated the fourth amendment when they attached a gps device to a car without a warrant. The majority opinion resolved the case without reaching the mosaic theory, and neither concurring opinion gave the issue extensive analysis. During the investigation, the police installed a gps tracking device in jones.
Justice sonia sotomayor pleads for the fourth amendment the. Jones not of the majority opinion itself, but of sotomayor s prescient concurrence to it. In this litigation, the government has conceded noncompliance with the warrant and has argued only that a warrant was not. Maynard, fbi agents planted a gps device on a car while it was on private property and then used it to track. Which argument do you find more persuasive in the jones case. Jun 24, 2018 sotomayors opinion in jones, which runs a mere six pages, proved hugely influential. The daughter of parents who moved to new york city from puerto rico, sotomayor was raised in a housing project in the bronx. She was appointed by president barack obama in may 2009 and confirmed that. Reflections on the oral argument in united states v. Sonia sotomayor, the first hispanic appointed to the united states supreme court, has written a candid memoir about her life leading up to that appointment in 2009. Hundreds of lower courts have cited it in decisions involving the clash of technology and privacy.
Jones, an appeal from the district of columbia circuit court of appeals that went on to the supreme court, on the issue of whether a warrant is needed to attach a gps tracking device to a vehicle. Sotomayor is known on the court for her trust in the judicial process, and her cutthroat attitude toward illprepared attorneys. Supreme court of the united states jesse guardado 177171 v. Sonia sotomayor the fearless federal trial court judge who saved major league baseball from a ruinous 1995 strike entered the record book as the first hispanic and the third woman to serve on the high court. In a speech at new york university, supreme court justice sonya sotomayor came out in support of the practice of jury nullification. Jan 02, 2014 it was sotomayors lonely concurrence in u. Jones, which has attracted widespread notice due to justice. Justice sonia sotomayor working on 3 books for young people.
The supreme court cares about your digital privacy the. Supreme court justice sotomayor supports practice of jury. The warrant they obtained required it to be executed within 10 days in the district of columbia. Justice alito also filed a concurring opinion, which was joined by justices ginsburg, breyer, and kagan. Justice sotomayor stakes out the middle ground in united states v.
The importance of justice sotomayors jones ruling in. Writings by justice sotomayor lii legal information institute. Police suspected antoine jones of engaging in drugrelated crimes and applied for a warrant to place a globalpositioningsystem tracking device gps on jones s car. Concurring opinions by justices sotomayor and alito urged the court to focus on the. Justice scalia, in jones, sees physical trespass as a floor, not a ceiling, for fourth amendment rights. District court judge in 1992 and was elevated to the u. Jones, the reasoning used to determine if a practice is a violation of fourth amendments rights has become even more blurred. Baer in this essay, professor miriam baer focuses on justice sotomayors concurrence in united states v.
Respondent jones was an owner and operator of a nightclub and came under suspicion of narcotics trafficking. Readers are requested to notify the reporter of decisions, supreme court of the united states, washington, d. On february 3, 2014, justice sonia sotomayor delivered the james a. Petitioner andrew kisela, a police officer in tucson, arizona, shot respondent amy hughes. Desiree sotomayor has 659 books on goodreads, and is currently reading all systems red by martha wells. She follows justice ruth bader ginsburg and former. Jones, a 2012 decision that involved a similar clash between contemporary technology and ancient constitutional principles. Sonia sotomayor, associate justice of the supreme court of the united states from 2009. Sonia sotomayors radical judicial activism the american. We have made a somewhat extended reference to these statutes to show that the guaranty of freedom from unreasonable searches and seizures by the fourth amendment has been construed.
United states court of appeals for the district of columbia circuit. Of old values and modernity lyle denniston police and hightech monitoring lyle denniston briefs and documents. Find all the books, read about the author, and more. In the supreme courts recent decision in united states v.
Aug 08, 2009 sotomayor has also joined the liberal majority on recent landmark cases. Her model defines building identification with political and legal institutions as an important goal for the court. Jones not of the majority opinion itself, but of sotomayors prescient concurrence to it. In 2009, she was confirmed as the first latina supreme court. On friday, june 22, the supreme court issued its muchanticipated opinion in carpenter v. Jan 27, 2012 javier sotomayor set up a new world record in 1993 at salamanca spain. Original art for the 2018 national book festival poster was created by gaby dalessandro, a dominican illustrator based in new york city. Antoine jones on writ of certiorari to the united states court of appeals for the district of columbia circuit january 23, 2012 justice alito, with whom justice ginsburg, justice breyer, and justice kagan join, concurring in the judgment. Justice sotomayor and the jurisprudence of procedural justice. Supreme court justice sonia sotomayor will launch her first childrens book, along with a young readers adaptation of her memoir, as part of the main stage lineup of authors at the 2018 national book festival, the library of congress announced today.
For one example, sotomayor mentioned united states v. Lexis 1063 brought to you by free law project, a nonprofit dedicated. Jan 14, 20 intelligent, gregarious and at times disarmingly personal, justice sonia sotomayor s memoir, my beloved world, recounts her trailblazing journey from a bronx housing project to a bench on the. The importance of justice sotomayors jones ruling in laying. A conversation with justice sotomayor the yale law journal. May 04, 2009 this is the first in a series of reports by tnr legal affairs editor jeffrey rosen about the strengths and weaknesses of the leading candidates on barack obamas supreme court shortlist. Jones s trial in october 2006 produced a hung jury on the conspiracy count. Sotomayor is working on three books for young people, penguin young readers told. Supreme court justice sonia sotomayor to join main stage. This transcript is adapted with slight editing from that lecture, which took the form of a conversation between justice sotomayor and linda greenhouse. Nov 08, 2011 i was at the supreme court this morning for the oral argument in united states v. Justice elena kagan framed the stakes in the case by asking michael dreeben, the deputy solicitor general, how this case was different from united states v. Lstd301 week 5 forum post briefly summarize katz v united. Nov 10, 2017 supreme court justices have written hundreds of books, but not many have written childrens books.
706 1439 535 126 946 8 812 643 797 230 752 442 1134 45 372 552 576 476 1200 321 185 601 331 398 363 1177 181 774 703 486 788 905 1222 1032 1493 40 407 1369 272 282 1344 128 551 1495 56 237 219 173 234